BREEAM

BREEAM has become the de facto measure or standard for the environmental performance of buildings in the UK.

Although voluntary, a number of Government departments and other public bodies either require or encourage the use of BREEAM. These include the Welsh Assembly Government, the Northern Ireland Executive, UK health authorities and the Department for Education. Many private sector clients and developers also use BREEAM to deliver sustainable buildings.

This article describes BREEAM new construction and how it is applied to non-domestic buildings, explains how construction materials are assessed under BREEAM and gives examples of BREEAM ‘Excellent and ‘Outstanding’ steel-framed buildings.

[top]What is BREEAM?

BREEAM (BRE Environmental Assessment Method) is the leading and most widely used environmental assessment method for buildings in the UK. It has been developed by the Building Research Establishment (BRE) has become the de facto measure of the environmental performance of UK buildings. Although currently voluntary, many publically funded/procured buildings are required to be BREEAM assessed and reach a minimum BREEAM rating.

The BREEAM methodology is updated regularly; the current version for UK non-domestic new buildings is BREEAM 2018 New Construction^[1]. A separate, similar scheme is available for refurbishing existing buildings. In addition to BREEAM UK New Construction, separate Technical Manuals are available for England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. These regional variants reflect the differences in building regulations in each country.

Eliot Park Innovation Centre, Nuneaton: Steel-framed, BREEAM 'Excellent' building

The primary aim of BREEAM New Construction is to mitigate the life cycle impacts of new buildings on the environment in a robust and cost effective manner. This is achieved through integration and use of the scheme by clients and their project teams at key stages in the design and procurement process. This enables the client, through the BREEAM Assessor and the BRE Global certification process, to measure, evaluate and reflect the performance of their building against best practice in an independent and robust manner.

Buildings assessed under BREEAM are awarded credits according to their predicted and actual performance, against 47 individual assessment issues within a range of nine environmental categories: management, energy, health and well being, pollution, transport, land use, ecology, materials and water. Each issue addresses a specific building related environmental impact or issue and has a number of ‘credits’ assigned to it. Credits are awarded where a building demonstrates that it meets the performance levels defined for that issue in the BREEAM 2018 New Construction scheme document^[1].

The number of ‘credits’ available for each individual assessment issue varies and generally the higher the number there are for a given issue, the more important that issue. Many credits are assessed using bespoke assessment tools and calculators developed by the BRE.

Credits are either mandatory, i.e. must be achieved for compliance, or voluntary. In addition, there are innovation credits which encourage exemplar performance or which recognise a building that innovates in the field of sustainable performance. The BREEAM 2018 New construction credits are summarised in the table.

**BREEAM 2018 New Construction environmental sections and assessment issues**
Energy	Water	Waste
Reduction of energy use and CO₂ emissions	Water consumption	Construction waste management
Energy monitoring	Water monitoring	Use of recycled and sustainably sourced aggregate
External lighting	Water leak detection	Operational waste
Low carbon design	Water efficient equipment	Speculative finishes
Energy efficient cold storage		Adaption to climate change
Energy efficient transportation systems		Design for disassembly and adaptability
Energy efficient laboratory systems
Energy efficient equipment (process)
Transport	Materials	Land use and ecology
Transport assessment and travel plan	Environmental impacts from construction products - Building LCA	Site selection
Sustainable transport measures	Environmental impacts from construction products - EPD	Identifying and understanding the risks and opportunities for the project
	Responsible sourcing of materials	Managing negative impacts on ecology
	Insulation	Change and enhancement of ecological value
	Designing for durability and resilience	Long term ecology management and maintenance
	Material efficiency
Health and wellbeing	Pollution	Management
Visual comfort	Impact of refrigerants	Project brief and design
Indoor air quality	Local air quality	Life cycle cost and service life planning
Thermal comfort	Flood and surface water management	Responsible construction practices
Acoustic performance	Reduction of night time light pollution	Commissioning and handover
Security	Reduction of noise pollution	Aftercare
Safe and healthy surroundings

Credits achieved are weighted according to environmental category and then summed to produce a single overall score on a scale of Unclassified, Pass, Good, Very Good, Excellent and Outstanding.

Although voluntary, a number of Government departments and other public bodies either require or encourage the use of BREEAM. These include the Welsh Assembly Government, the Northern Ireland Executive, UK health authorities and the Department for Education. Many private sector clients and developers also use BREEAM to deliver sustainable buildings.

Building projects are assessed by registered BREEAM assessors and reviewed by a third party (BRE Global) before being awarded a certificate. Since 2008 it has been compulsory to undertake a ‘Post Construction Review’ to confirm that the ‘as built’ information correlates with the design information.

The Design Stage (DS) assessment and interim certified BREEAM rating confirms the building’s performance at the design stage of the life cycle. The Post Construction Stage (PCS) assessment and BREEAM rating confirms the final ‘as-built’ performance of the building at the new construction stage of the life cycle. A final PCS assessment is completed and certified after practical completion of the building works.

The BREEAM certificate, issued by the National Scheme Operator (NSO - BRE Global in the UK), provides formal verification that the Assessor has completed an assessment of a building in accordance with the requirements of the scheme and its quality standards and procedures. A BREEAM certificate therefore provides assurance to any interested party that a building’s BREEAM rating, at the time of certification, accurately reflects its performance against the BREEAM standard.

All BREEAM assessed and certified buildings are listed on Green Book Live (along with a directory of licensed BREEAM Assessors).

Anyone wishing to verify the BREEAM rating of a building can do so by either checking a building’s BREEAM certificate, which will contain the certification mark or by searching Green Book Live for a specific listing.

[top]BREEAM scoring

The BREEAM rating benchmarks for new UK construction projects assessed using the 2018 version of BREEAM are as follows:

**BREEAM 2018 rating benchmarks**
BREEAM rating	% score
Outstanding	≥ 85
Excellent	≥ 70
Very Good	≥ 55
Good	≥ 45
Pass	≥ 30
Unclassified	< 30

The BREEAM rating benchmark levels enable a client and other stakeholders to compare an individual building’s performance with other BREEAM rated buildings and the typical sustainability performance of new non-domestic buildings in the UK.

BRE claims that each BREEAM rating level broadly represents performance equivalent the following measures although there is no published evidence to substantiate this:

Outstanding: Less than top 1% of UK new non-domestic buildings (innovator)
Excellent: Top 10% of UK new non-domestic buildings (best practice)
Very Good: Top 25% of UK new non-domestic buildings (advanced good practice)
Good: Top 50% of UK new non-domestic buildings (intermediate good practice)
Pass: Top 75% of UK new non-domestic buildings (standard good practice)

[top]Minimum standards

Although BREEAM was designed to be a flexible scoring system in which different credits could be ‘traded’, since 2008 BREEAM has included minimum standards of performance in some key areas.

To achieve a particular BREEAM rating, the minimum overall percentage score must be achieved and compliance must be shown with the minimum standards shown in the table.

**Minimum BREEAM standards by rating level**
BREEAM issue	Minimum standards by BREEAM rating level
BREEAM issue	Pass	Good	Very Good	Excellent	Outstanding
Man 03: Responsible construction processes	None	None	None	One credit (Responsible construction management)	One credit (Responsible construction management
Man 04: Commissioning and handover	None	None	One credit Commissioning test schedule and responsibilities	One credit Commissioning test schedule and responsibilities	One credit Commissioning test schedule and responsibilities
Man 04: Commissioning and handover	None	None	Criterion 11 (Building user guide)	Criterion 11 (Building user guide	Criterion 11 (Building user guide
Man 05: Aftercare	None	None	None	One credit (Commissioning implementation)	One credit (Commissioning implementation)
Ene 01: Reduction of energy use and CO₂ emissions	None	None	None	Four credits (Energy performance)	Six credits (Energy performance) and Four credits (Energy modeling and reporting))
Ene 02: Energy monitoring	None	None	One credit (First submetering credit)	One credit (First submetering credit)	One credit (First submetering credit)
Wat 01: Water consumption	None	One credit	One credit	One credit	Two credits
Wat 02: Water monitoring	None	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only
Mat 03: Responsible sourcing of construction products	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only	Criterion 1 only
Wst 01: Construction waste management	None	None	None	None	One credit
Wst 03: Operational waste	None	None	None	One credit	One credit

BREEAM uses a weighting system derived from a combination of consensus based weightings and ranking by a panel of experts, to weight the scores achieved in each of the nine environmental categories. Different weightings are applied depending on the scope of the assessment, i.e. shell only, shell and core only and fully fitted out. The weightings for a 'Fully fitted out' building are shown in the table.

BREEAM Environmental section weightings
(fully fitted out)
Environmental section	Weighting (%)
Management	11
Health & Wellbeing	14
Energy	16
Transport	10
Water	7
Materials	15
Waste	6
Land Use & Ecology	13
Pollution	8
Total	100
Innovation (additional)	10

The same set of rankings underpins the scoring mechanisms in the BRE Green Guide to Specification^[2] and the BRE Environmental Profiling Method for construction materials^[3].

The table below shows an example of how the scores in the nine BREEAM sections are aggregated to produce a final BREEAM score which, in this case, translates into a BREEAM rating of Very Good, i.e. a final BREEAM score >55.

**Example of how the overall BREEAM rating is calculated**
BREEAM section	Credits achieved	Credits available	% of credits achieved	Section weighting (Fully fitted)	Section score
Management	14	21	66.67	0.11	7.33
Health & Wellbeing	12	22	54.55	0.14	7.64
Energy	15	31	48.39	0.16	7.74
Transport	8	12	66.67	0.10	6.67
Water	4	10	40.00	0.07	2.68
Materials	8	14	57.17	0.15	8.57
Waste	3	6	50.00	0.06	3.00
Land Use & Ecology	5	10	50.00	0.13	6.50
Pollution	8	13	61.54	0.08	4.92
Innovation	2	10	20.00	0.10	2.00
				Final BREEAM score	57.06
				BREEAM rating	Very Good

[top]Innovation credits

BREEAM first introduced innovation credits in 2008. The aim of innovation credits is to support and encourage innovation in construction. An additional 1% can be added to the overall building score for each innovation credit; up to maximum of 10 credits, i.e. 10%.

Innovation credits can be awarded in two ways:

By meeting exemplary performance criteria defined within an existing BREEAM issue i.e. going beyond the standard BREEAM assessment criteria and therefore best practice. Only some assessment issues have exemplary performance criteria.
By application to BRE Global to have a particular building technology or feature, design or construction method or process recognised as ‘innovative’. If the application is successful and subsequently building compliance is verified, an ‘innovation credit’ can be awarded.

[top]Material assessment within BREEAM

Under BREEAM, construction materials are assessed under the five issues shown.

**BREEAM 2018 Material assessment issues**
Issue	Description	Credits available
Mat 01	Environmental impacts from construction products - Building life cycle assessment (LCA) Life cycle impacts	Up to 7 (depending on the building type)
Mat 02	Environmental impacts from construction products - Environmental Product Declarations (EPD)	1
Mat 03	Responsible sourcing of construction products	4
Mat 05	Designing for durability and resilience	1
Mat 06	Material efficiency	1

The only minimum standard under the Material section of BREEAM 2018 is for Mat 03 (Responsible sourcing of materials) where Criterion 1 is required for all BREEAM rating levels.

Further information on the assessment of materials under BREEAM is available in the Materials section of the BREEAM New Construction Technical Manual^[1].